In 8th grade, I thought I was unstoppable. A growth spurt gave me height, leverage, and what felt like destiny. I could clear high jump bars with a scissors kick while others struggled. No training, no technique, just raw advantage.
I beat everyone in my school, made it to my town’s track and field meet, and placed well. I was on top of the high jump world. (Albeit it was a very small world!)
In my freshman year of high school, I was toast. Everyone else had learned the Fosbury Flop…the backward roll that revolutionized high jumping. My height advantage evaporated. Suddenly, I couldn’t clear the same bars, and I didn’t even make the varsity team.
Lesson learned: Growth can make you lazy. It can trick you into thinking you’re great when you’re just tall.
Churches fall into the same trap. Growth feels like validation: more people, more buzz, more money. However, growth can be toxic if it masks underlying weaknesses. It’s a sugar high that makes leaders feel invincible when, in reality, they’re just riding momentum.
The hard truth: the very growth you’re celebrating may be setting you up for decline.
Let’s break it down. Five areas where unchecked growth quietly kills future growth:
* First-Time Guest Capture Rate
* New Donor Retention Gap
* Follow-Up Speed to First Touch
* Kids/Students Capacity Ratio
* Staffing Leverage
1. First-Time Guest Capture Rate: Growth Without Names = Decline in Disguise
If you don’t know who your guests are, they don’t exist. Churches celebrate attendance spikes but often fail at the most basic task: capturing guest info.
Here’s the brutal math: in many churches, only 3 out of 10 first-time guests fill out a connect card or text-in form. That means, 70% leave without a trace. Imagine running a restaurant that never records who dines there. That’s not strategy…it’s negligence. [
ref]
Unchecked growth hides failure. When 100 people show up, you don’t feel the loss of the 70 who disappear. But fast-forward six months: you’ll plateau, scratching your head about why your “record Sundays” aren’t leading to real growth.
If your church is growing, you should see new visitors each week—roughly 2% of your average attendance. If your attendance is 1,000, that means week in and week out, you are averaging 20 guests that you could contact, follow up with, and invite to be a part of your community. If you don’t see this regularly, you are missing guests.
Without this new guest information, you are just gathering a crowd that you won’t be able to move towards deeper community and connection. Your growth will plateau and slide into decline. You will be left wondering where all the people went.
* Audit your capture rate for the last three months. Not an estimate, an actual number.
* Set a benchmark goal: at least 2% of every single week should be first-time guests that you can contact.
* Create frictionless ways to respond: text-in, QR codes, digital follow-up.
* Use an “ethical bribe” …a gift that makes people want to give you their info.
* Assign accountability: one staff member or volunteer owns the process every week.
