This week, Katy is taking us to Calhoun County, Alabama in 2018 for a case that shattered a small community. It’s the story of Kelsey Williams, a 26-year-old woman found murdered along Highway 431 in 2018. Join us as we follow how investigators uncovered the truth and brought two brothers to justice for one of East Alabama’s most haunting crimes.

This week, Scott’s back with Part Two of The Cocaine Quarterback. When the walls closed in, Owen Hanson’s empire began to crumble — and the trail of violence, greed, and betrayal left behind was almost cinematic. From hidden offshore accounts to undercover FBI stings, this episode follows the dramatic fall of a man who thought he could outsmart everyone. Join us as we uncover how a former football star’s empire of excess finally came crashing down.

This week, Scott’s taking us to California in the early 2000s for the story of Owen Hanson — a former USC football player whose double life blurred the line between athlete and criminal. What started with small-time gambling and drug deals soon grew into an international operation that moved millions in cocaine and cash. In Part One of The Cocaine Quarterback, we follow how a college star’s ambition and arrogance set the stage for a global downfall. This is Part One of two part series.

This week, Kelly’s taking us to 1990 in the Texas Panhandle. It’s the story of David Milner — a man whose deadly rampage unfolded on Friday the 13th. What began as an ordinary day soon turned into a night of terror that would haunt a small town for decades. Join us as we explore how superstition, rage, and timing collided to create one of Texas’s most chilling crimes.

This week, Katy’s taking us back to 1987 for a case that blurs the line between horror and reality. It’s the story of Ruthie Mae McCoy — a woman who called 911 to say someone was breaking into her apartment through the bathroom mirror. Her brutal murder would later inspire the terrifying legend of Candyman. Join us as we uncover the real story behind the movie myth and the tragedy that haunted Chicago’s housing projects.

This week, Kelly’s taking us back to 2014 for a case that blurs the line between urban legend and reality. It’s the story of the Slenderman stabbings — when two twelve-year-old girls tried to kill their best friend to prove their loyalty to a fictional monster. Join us as we unpack how an internet myth turned into a real-life nightmare.

This week Scott takes us across the Pond to the 1960s in England and revolves around unlicensed, offshore radio stations like Radio Caroline. 

This week Katy takes us to the Tremont neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio from 2002 to 2013 to tell the story of the girls involved in the Cleveland Abductions.

This week Katy takes us to Canada to discuss the bizarre events that took place at the Pan house in November of 2010. We did not see this one coming. Don't worry, we will be back next week with an all NEW story!

This week Kelly takes us to Los Angeles, CA in 2013 to discuss the mysterious death of college student Elisa Lam at the Cecil Hotel.

This week Scott takes us to 1981 in Philadelphia to tell the story of Joey Coyle and the mission million dollars that changed his life forever.

This week Kelly takes us back to Austin, Texas to finish (sort of) the story of the murders of four teenage girls that took place in the local yogurt shop. This is part 2 of a 2 part series.

This week Kelly takes us to 1991 in Austin, Texas to tell the story of the murders of four teenage girls that took place in the local yogurt shop. This is part 1 of a 2 part series.

This week the team is joined by friend of the show, Ethan Laney! Ethan tells the story of an even that terrified the nation, the D.C. Sniper. You do not want to miss this one.

This week Scott takes us to the University of Texas at Austin in 1966 to tell the story of the mass murder committed by Marine veteran and sharp shooter Charles Whitman. This is an older one, but you do not want to miss it!

This week Scott takes us to Chicago in 1966 to tell the horrific story of the crimes committed by Richard Benjamin Speck. 

This week we are joined in studio by returning special guest Stephanie West. Stephanie helps the team tackle the University of Idaho Murders committed by Bryan Kohberger.

This week Katy takes us to Wylie, Texas in 1980 to tell the real life story of Candy Montgomery and the axe murder of Betty Gore. 

This week Scott takes us to Plainfield, Wisconsin in 1957 to tell the horrendous story of the "Plainfield Ghoul" himself, Ed Gein, and how his crimes are still inspiring the horror genre today.

This week Scott takes us to New York in the 1980s to tell the story of a multitude of crimes that culminated in the mass murder coined "The CBS Murders."