s your church starving for care or clarity? Too often, pastors feel torn between preaching the Word and shepherding the people, but the truth is, your church can’t thrive without both. In this episode of the Enduring Church Podcast, Nathan and Michael unpack how this false divide has weakened churches and burned out leaders. They dive into why preaching is shepherding, how to build a team that helps meet real needs, and what time management looks like when you’re carrying the spiritual weight of a congregation. If you’ve ever felt like you can’t do it all, you’re right. But there’s a better way forward. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

Biblical masculinity should resonate with strength, sacrifice, and leadership—but in today’s churches, many men feel sidelined, silenced, or bored. In this episode of the Enduring Church Podcast, Nathan and Michael unpack why modern churches are struggling to engage men and what it means to reclaim a robust vision of biblical manhood. They explore how worship culture, emotionalism, and consumer-driven discipleship have created a church environment that often feels more therapeutic than transformational. The conversation dives into cultural overcorrections like “toxic masculinity,” the rise of incels, and why many men are more comfortable retreating into video games than rising to lead their families and communities. Drawing from Scripture, personal stories, and even emotional intelligence training used by Navy SEALs, the episode offers pastors practical ways to disciple men who are eager for purpose, challenge, and spiritual grit. It’s raw, bold, and a timely call to reawaken the warrior spirit within the Church. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

Tongues, prophecy, and healing spark some of the deepest divides in today’s church. Are these gifts an actual work of the Spirit or a dangerous distraction? In this episode of the Enduring Church Podcast, Nathan and Michael delve into the tension between cessationists and continuationists, share compelling stories from their ministry experiences, and explore how pastors can approach the sign gifts with wisdom, humility, and balance. They also reflect on the global church’s perspective, where spiritual gifts often look very different than those in the West, and consider what it means for unity in a post-Christian culture. The conversation is honest, practical, and aimed at helping leaders shepherd their congregations faithfully in the midst of controversy. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this sobering episode, we explore how pastors and church leaders can shepherd their congregations through the national grief surrounding the murder of Charlie Kirk. We discuss the deep spiritual need for God in moments like this, the real danger of civil war rhetoric escalating into action, and the urgent reminder that vengeance belongs to the Lord. We also unpack how to disciple believers toward a kingdom-first worldview—one that isn’t shaped by fear, rage, or tribalism, but by the cross of Christ. Stay with us as we challenge the Church to be a place of healing, clarity, and Gospel-centered perspective in an increasingly fractured culture. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

What happens when ministry becomes more draining than life-giving? When the passion fades, the pressure builds, and you’re left wondering if you can keep going. In this episode, we get honest about the emotional, spiritual, and practical weight of leadership in the church—especially when the joy that once fueled your calling starts to slip away. Whether you’re a pastor shouldering the demands of a congregation or a lay leader juggling ministry with everyday life, this conversation is for you. Stick around till the end—we’ll share practical ways to offload the work that’s no longer essential, so you can focus on what God has actually called you to do. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

The culture has shifted, and it’s not moving back. In this episode, we talk about what it means to pastor in a world where Christianity no longer holds cultural power. But it’s not all bad news. We explore why the death of cultural Christianity might be good for the Church, and how this moment could purify and strengthen our witness. We also unpack the “vibe shift” that’s followed recent elections, the growing appeal of the trad movement, and what all of this means for shepherds trying to lead with clarity, conviction, and compassion. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we explore the growing tension between the self-help message and the true gospel of Jesus Christ. Has the church traded repentance for personal development? Are we offering inspiration when what people need is transformation? Michael and Nathan unpack the subtle ways the self-help gospel creeps into our preaching, how it shifts our focus from Christ to self, and why the cross must remain at the center of our message. If you’re wrestling with what it means to faithfully preach the gospel in a culture obsessed with self-fulfillment, this conversation is for you. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

Disunity is more than disagreement—it’s what happens when conflict turns into division. In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we unpack what disunity really is and what it isn’t. We explore how pastors and church leaders can spot the difference between healthy tension and harmful division, and how to respond when relationships start to fracture. More importantly, we discuss the challenging yet hopeful path toward reconciliation—and how the church can lead the way in restoring unity without compromising truth.

Church hurt is real, but it’s not always what we think. In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we unpack what church hurt is (and what it isn’t), share some of our own experiences, and explore how pastors can respond with grace, truth, and a focus on healing. Whether your church has wounded you or you are walking with someone who has, this conversation offers hope, clarity, and a path toward restoration. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we examine the rise of online church. Is it truly fostering worship, community, and discipleship, or has it become a convenient substitute that weakens the local body? We discuss why simply streaming services is not the same as gathering as the Church, the dangers of turning worship into passive content, and how pastors can call their people back to embodied, biblical community. If you’ve been wondering about the long-term impact of online church, this episode pulls no punches. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we explore a strange but familiar reaction in the church: why do we get so weird when celebrities come to faith in Christ? From instant platforms to public discipleship, we discuss the tension between celebrating salvation and placing unrealistic expectations on new believers. Should fame fast-track someone into spiritual influence? And what does a wise, biblical response look like? Whether you’re encouraged, skeptical, or just confused by celebrity conversions, this episode brings clarity and caution to the conversation. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we examine the growing influence of the celebrity pastor mindset, where charisma, platform, and personal brand often overshadow humility, service, and faithfulness. We explore how this mentality takes root, why it’s so tempting in modern ministry, and the damage it can do to pastors, congregations, and the church's witness. This episode is a call to return to servant leadership, to prioritize character over charisma, and to remember that pastors are called to shepherd, not perform. If you’re navigating leadership in a platform-driven culture, this conversation is for you. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we tackle a timely and often tense question: How can the church love its country without losing its focus on the Kingdom of God? We explore the difference between healthy patriotism and idolatry, the distinct roles of the government and the church, and how pastors can guide their congregations toward gospel-centered priorities. Michael Davis also shares from his experience serving in Iraq, offering a personal perspective on patriotism, faith, and where our ultimate allegiance belongs. If you’ve felt the tension between national pride and Kingdom mission, this conversation is for you. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we take an honest look at the early church—its simplicity, its power, its mess—and ask the big question: Should we model our churches after it today? We explore what the early church got right, what challenges it faced, and how much of its structure and rhythm still applies in a modern, complex world. Is Acts 2 a blueprint or just a snapshot? And are we idealizing something that was never meant to be duplicated? This episode will challenge assumptions and invite pastors to reflect deeply on how we shape our churches today. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we speak directly to pastors navigating the delicate and often painful reality of church hurt. We explore what church hurt really is and what it isn’t, and how leaders can faithfully shepherd those who’ve been deeply wounded by the very place meant to offer healing. From rebuilding trust to creating a culture of safety, we offer practical and pastoral insight for loving the wounded well without losing your own footing in the process. If you’re a leader who wants to be part of the solution, this conversation is for you. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we explore the real-world tension of bivocational ministry. Is working a second job while pastoring a strategic advantage—or a heavy sacrifice? We explore the benefits, challenges, and spiritual dynamics of bivocational leadership, discussing how it impacts pastors, their families, and the churches they serve. Whether you’re considering bivocational ministry, living it right now, or trying to support someone who is, this conversation offers honest insights and practical wisdom for navigating the path well. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

Money is one of the most uncomfortable topics in the church, but are we talking about it the wrong way? In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we’re joined by Jason Summers, a major giving officer with decades of experience, to expose the most significant mistakes churches make when discussing money, tithing, and generosity. Are churches guilt-tripping people into giving? Are they too vague? Too pushy? Too afraid to talk about money at all? We tackle these tough questions and offer practical, biblical solutions to help churches create a culture of generosity without manipulation that encourages faithful giving without turning people away. If you’ve ever wrestled with how to talk about money in the church, this episode is a must-listen! Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we tackle a pressing issue: Why Are Young People Leaving Your Church? Churches across the country are struggling to retain the next generation, but is the problem with them or how we’re engaging them? We dive into the biggest reasons young adults are walking away, the mistakes churches make when trying to reach them, and practical, biblical strategies to bridge the gap. If your church is serious about connecting with the next generation, this episode is a must-listen! Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com

In this episode of The Enduring Church Podcast, we tackle a tough but necessary topic: What Do You Do if Your Church Turns Against You? Whether you’re a pastor facing conflict, a leader dealing with division, or a church member feeling betrayed, this conversation is for you. We discuss real-life scenarios, biblical wisdom, and practical steps for handling church hurt, navigating difficult seasons, and staying faithful to your calling even when the people around you seem to turn away. If you’ve ever felt abandoned by your church, you’re not alone—tune in for encouragement and guidance. Follow the Guys! Michael Davis: https://x.com/Davis_FDM Nathan Castleberry: https://x.com/nathancberry Learn more about First Day Marketing: https://firstdaymarketing.com