#Scotland #MalcolmRobertson #business #politics #innovation #culture #energytransition #narrative #entrepreneurship #publiclife #economy #courage #patience #perseverance #investment #educateyourself
In this episode, I'm talking with Malcolm Robertson - someone who is immersed in the Scottish business, media and political scene but who doesn't often appear in the public eye himself.
Malcolm is one of my all time favourite people that I've met since embarking on this journey, because he not only provides a unique perspective on Scotland's economy and politics...
He's also willing to go places that others find uncomfortable... to talk about the culture, spirit and mindset at the heart of our public life, and how we can transform it.
Anyone who knows me, knows how pre-occupied I am with this - so you'll understand why I love talking with him so much!
So expect less facts and figures in this episode but more of an inquiry into the pioneering spirit and culture of Scotland's past, where that spirit is bubbling up in the present and how we can unlock it for the bright future that is within our grasp. Enjoy!
-------
Timecodes:
00:00 Intro
03:08 From Tenacity to Timidity...& Back Again
05:50 Scottish Innovation & Interplay with Politics
09:09 Risk, Failure, and the Need for Courage
15:07 The New Brand Scotland... With the Old Perseverance
19:35 Patience & Lifting Our Sights
24:11 Short-Termism Affecting Third Sector
28:46 Over-reliance on Government & Taking Radical Responsibility
33:34 The Diminishing Scottish Business Media
37:06 Creating a Supportive Business Environment
42:29 Who Can We Learn From? English Mayors & Scottish Islanders
46:36 Transformational Opportunities for Scotland
50:02 Personal Psyche; Impact on National Psyche
59:14 Public Knowledge & Changing the Story
------
Malcolm Robertson is Founding Partner at Charlotte Street Partners - Scotland’s leading communications and public affairs agency. He also chair the board of trustees of Street Soccer Scotland and the Scotland advisory board of Unicef UK. You can find out more about Malcolm here: https://www.charlottestreetpartners.com/people/malcolm-robertson-charlotte-street-partners/
-----
Instagram: / public_knowledge_pod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowle...
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowle...
Linkedin: public_knowledge_pod
#money #scotland #economy #jobs #energytransition #globaltrends #growth #educateyourself #educate #business #investment
_____
The most important Scotland-England rivalry you’ve probably NEVER heard of… is the one that matters most for the health of the Scottish Finances!
Join me in Part 2 of this interview with Professor Graeme Roy - where we unpack:
* The largely unknown financial formula that puts us in direct competition with England;
* How Scottish stereotypes could be holding our economy back; and
* The need to move beyond a Westminster focus and scrutinise Scottish Government decision making...
If you’re curious about getting under the skin of the real, and really very important story, of Scotland’s changing economic fortunes and how they will impact us all, then this episode is for you!
_____
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
01:22 Shades of Economic Growth
04:30 Link: Economic Growth & Public Services
06:17 Where Scotland-England Rivalry GETS REAL
09:47 Tax Revenue Growth: Impact on Scottish Budget
11:07 The Importance of High-Quality Jobs
14:52 Scotland's Dynamic & Evolving Economy
19:48 Stories Matter: Mythbusting is Critical to Scotland's Future Economy
21:20 Improving What Scotland DOES Control
25:35 Where is the Vibrancy, the New Ideas, the Challenge?
_____
Graeme Roy is Chair of the Scottish Fiscal Commission, Scotland’s official independent economic and fiscal forecaster, and Professor of Economics, Deputy Head of the College of Social Sciences and Assistant Vice Principal at the University of Glasgow.
He was previously Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute at the University of Strathclyde and a former Senior Civil Servant in the Scottish Government, where he was Head of the First Minister’s Policy Unit.
His research focus is on economic policy and devolution. He is a regular commentator on the Scottish economy, including a column for The Herald newspaper.
He is a past independent adviser to the Scottish Parliament’s Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee, and a former member of the UK Government’s Scottish Business Taskforce and the Scottish Government’s National Economic Transformation Council.
Outside of university, Graeme is a board member of Stirling Community Enterprise a social enterprise based in the Raploch area that supports community-based training and employment.
In 2023, Graeme was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (RSE). In 2024, he was awarded the Adam Smith Prize by the RSE for his “substantial contribution to public policy and public life in Scotland”.
You can find out more about Graeme’s work here: https://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/business/staff/graemeroy/#biography
_____
Instagram: / public_knowledge_pod
#money#scotland#economy #manufacturing #energytransition #globaltrends#growth#educateyourself#educate#business#investment
_____
Think Scotland’s economy is all about salmon, whisky and energy? Then think again!
In part 1 of this interview with Professor Graeme Roy - we start demystifying the Scottish economy:
If you’re curious about getting under the skin of the real, and really very exciting story, of Scotland’s changing economic fortunes and how they will impact us all, then this episode is for you!
_____
Chapters
00:00 Intro
01:28 Scotland's Economy in a Global Context
04:57 Scottish Manufacturing - Past & Future
08:17 Scotland's Position within the UK Economy
10:32 Grand Challenges Facing Scottish Economy
13:51 Key Sectors of Economy - Present & Future
16:37 Playing Catch Up? Scotland's Public Discourse
19:19 Scotland's Economy - Falling Through the Cracks?
_____
Graeme Roy is Chair of the Scottish Fiscal Commission, Scotland’s official independent economic and fiscal forecaster, and Professor of Economics, Deputy Head of the College of Social Sciences and Assistant Vice Principal at the University of Glasgow.
He was previously Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute at the University of Strathclyde and a former Senior Civil Servant in the Scottish Government, where he was Head of the First Minister’s Policy Unit.
His research focus is on economic policy and devolution. He is a regular commentator on the Scottish economy, including a column for The Herald newspaper.
He is a past independent adviser to the Scottish Parliament’s Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee, and a former member of the UK Government’s Scottish Business Taskforce and the Scottish Government’s National Economic Transformation Council.
Outside of university, Graeme is a board member of Stirling Community Enterprise a social enterprise based in the Raploch area that supports community-based training and employment.
In 2023, Graeme was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (RSE). In 2024, he was awarded the Adam Smith Prize by the RSE for his “substantial contribution to public policy and public life in Scotland”.
You can find out more about Graeme’s work here: https://www.gla.ac.uk/schools/business/staff/graemeroy/#biography
_____
Instagram: / public_knowledge_pod
TikTok:https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowle...
Bluesky:https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowle...
Linkedin: / about
#northsea #oilandgas #money #scotland #economy #growth #public #finance #barnett #fiscal #tax #revenue #spending #educateyourself #educate #business #investment
_____
Where does Scotland’s money come from, and why should you care? Part 2!
In this episode of Public Knowledge, Professor Mairi Spowage gives us the answers!
Speaking with Sepi Golzari-Munro in part 2 of her interview, she reveals:
- The (known) truth about the North Sea oil and gas money (and what we might never know);
- Why many of the services, networks and systems - essentially most of our national infrastructure - feels like it's creaking; and
- How the Scottish budgeting process - that determines how much money we have to invest in our nation - actually works.
If you’re curious about how taxes, government funding, and policies shape your everyday life, this episode is for you!
_____
Chapters
00:00 Intro
01:26 North Sea Money - Where did it go?
04:50 More devolution; more dependence?
07:16 Who is accountable?
10:11 What About the Trade-Offs
12:38 Scottish Govt BUDGET - Process & Challenges
15:30 Borrowing Powers & Our Crumbling Infrastructure
17:35 Capital Spending & Long-Term Investment
21:05 Key Interventions for a Prosperous Future
22:55 What Should Be Public Knowledge?
23:54 Outro
_____
Mairi Spowage is a Professor of Practice and Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute.
Her areas of expertise include economic policy, economic statistics, national accounting, public sector finances, and economic and fiscal forecasting. She is regularly asked to give evidence on economic and fiscal matters at Parliamentary Committees, such as the Finance and Constitution Committee and the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee.
Previously, Mairi was the Deputy Chief Executive of the Scottish Fiscal Commission and the Head of National Accounts at the Scottish Government, and has over 15 years of experience working in different areas of statistics and analysis, including transport, household surveys and performance measurement.
More information about Mairi and her work can be found at: https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/persons/mairi-spowage
_____
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/public_knowledge_pod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowledge_pod?_t=8sIhMOiLosj&_r=1
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowledgepod.bsky.social
Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/public-knowledge-pod/about
#money #scotland #economy #growth #public #finance #barnett #fiscal #tax #revenue #spending #educateyourself #educate #business #investment
_____
Where does Scotland’s money come from, and why should you care? Part 1!
In this episode of Public Knowledge, Professor Mairi Spowage gives us the answers!
Speaking with Sepi Golzari-Munro in part 1 of a two part interview, she reveals the truth about the money that flows into the Scottish Government's coffers, the famous Barnett Formula and the link between economic growth and public services. They explore the impact of tax on individual behaviour as well as business investment and where Scotland might need more money per person, than the rest of the UK.
If you’re curious about how taxes, government funding, and policies shape your everyday life, this episode is for you!
_____
Timecodes
00:00 Introduction
02:30 Why care about Public Finances?
05:30 Public Finances Health Check
07:20 Sources of Scotland's Public Finances
09:58 Income Tax in Scotland
11:12 Penny Wise; Pound Foolish?
14:19 Tax: Impact on Investment & Growth?
16:03 Mythbusting - No Growth/De-Growth
17:48 Direct Link: Growth & Public Services
19:08 'FISCAL' : WTF does it mean?!
20:19 Barnett Formula: History & Operation
_____
Mairi Spowage is a Professor of Practice and Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute.
Her areas of expertise include economic policy, economic statistics, national accounting, public sector finances, and economic and fiscal forecasting. She is regularly asked to give evidence on economic and fiscal matters at Parliamentary Committees, such as the Finance and Constitution Committee and the Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Committee.
Previously, Mairi was the Deputy Chief Executive of the Scottish Fiscal Commission and the Head of National Accounts at the Scottish Government, and has over 15 years of experience working in different areas of statistics and analysis, including transport, household surveys and performance measurement.
More information about Mairi and her work can be found at: https://pureportal.strath.ac.uk/en/persons/mairi-spowage
_____
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/public_knowledge_pod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowledge_pod?_t=8sIhMOiLosj&_r=1
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowledgepod.bsky.social
Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/public-knowledge-pod/about
#Scotland, #ScottishParliament #Holyrood, #Westminster, #Brexit, #Devolution, #Government, #Economy, #Labour MPs, SNP #history #politics
Professor Nicola McEwen unpacks the complexities of Scottish devolution, exploring its historical context, the evolution of powers within the Scottish Parliament, and the intricate and evolving intergovernmental relations between the Scottish Government in Holyrood and the UK Government in Westminster.
In this conversation with Sepi Golzari-Munro, they discuss the significance of the Scottish Parliament's establishment in 1999, the evolution of the Parliament’s powers, the transformational impact of Brexit on the relationship between the Scottish and UK Parliaments, the need for more transparency in the way the Scottish and UK Government’s interact and make decisions and what the future of this relationship may hold.
_____
00:00 Intro
02:13 Historical Forces - Establishing Scottish Parliament
05:15 Home Rule Movement & Political Dynamics
10:42 Evolution of Devolution - How Scotland's Powers Have Changed
15:31 New Powers: Political Fudge or Necessarily Complex?
18:49 No Complexity, No Devolution
22:20 MORE Politicians?!
25:27 Weakest Link - Government Relations
28:52 With & Without EU - Brexit Impact on UK Home Affairs
31:02 A Necessary Evil? Scottish Powers Curtailed
38:43 Commitment to Devolution Questioned
41:52 Fixing Future Holyrood-Westminster Relationship
44:57 What Should be Public Knowledge?
46:06 Conclusion
_____
Professor Nicola McEwen is a Professor of Public Policy and Governance in the College of Social Sciences and Director of the Centre for Public Policy at the University of Glasgow. She was previously at Edinburgh University from 2001, first as Lecturer, then Senior Lecturer in 2006, and as Professor of Territorial Politics from 2014. She was founding Co-Director of the Centre on Constitutional Change, where she remains a Research Fellow.
Nicola completed a Senior Research Fellowship with the ESRC UK in a Changing Europe, having previously been Principal Investigator of one of its prestigious Brexit Priority Grants. Her project, entitled A Family of Nations? Brexit, Devolution and the Union, explored intergovernmental relations in UK-EU negotiations, and the implications of Brexit for devolution and the future of the Union.
From 2019-2022, Nicola was Research Fellow in a major ESRC-funded project, Between Two Unions: The Constitutional Future of the Islands after Brexit, where she led the research strand charting the evolution of intergovernmental relations.
She has published widely in the field of territorial politics, nationalism, multi-level government and policy-making, and multi-level parties and elections. She is actively involved in informing debate within the wider policy and political community, through with extensive experience in providing analysis in broadcast, print and social media, public engagement, advice to governments and parliamentary committees, and consultancy.
_____
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPItG7O45Xu5FXQX2zkKo0Q
Instagram: / public_knowledge_pod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowle...
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowle...
Linkedin: / about
______ Listen to all episodes: Youtube, Spotify and Apple ____ Video graphics by Nicholas Munro https://www.nicholasmunrovisual.com/
#Scotland, #NicolaSturgeon, Chief of Staff, #Holyrood, #Westminster, #Brexit, #Devolution, #Government, #Economy, #Labour MPs, SNP
Nicola Sturgeon’s former Chief of Staff, Liz Lloyd, reveals the power dynamics between the Scottish and UK Governments and their impact on how we live our lives in Scotland.
Speaking with Sepi Golzari-Munro, she reveals what Nicola Sturgeon was really like, the impact of Brexit on the relationship between the UK and Scottish governments, whether the Scottish Parliament's powers have been rolled back and the role of SNP MPs and Scottish Labour MPs in Westminster. She goes on to highlight the economic challenges Scotland faces and the potential for future collaboration between the governments.
00:00 Introduction
01:44 What is a Chief of Staff?
02:46 Working for Nicola Sturgeon
05:17 Best of Times - Worst of Times
06:26 Historical Context - Who Runs Scotland?
07:40 A Tale of Two Governments
10:05 Brexit and the Breakdown of Cooperation
13:24 Rolling Back Devolution? The Internal Market Act
18:23 Escalating Tensions: Muscular Unionism or Devolution Overreach
26:06 Proper Role for Westminster in Devolution
28:01 Scotland and Devolution - Always an Afterthought?
32:10 Getting Messy and Stifling the Scottish Economy?
39:17 The Role of Scottish MPs in Westminster
41:08 How Should Scottish Labour MPs Advocate for Scotland?
46:37 Crown Estate Scotland and Scottish Ministers' Raid
49:05 The Council of Nations and Regions
50:53 Conclusion
51:13 Outro
51:49 End Plate
Liz Lloyd was Strategic Adviser and Chief of Staff to the First Minister of Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon. She helped design and deliver the Scottish Government’s legislative agenda for more than a decade covering all areas of policy, with a particular focus on the transition to net zero, the development of new economic opportunities and international relations.
Liz played a central role in the Scottish Government’s approach to policy and communications through the COVID pandemic, supported the development of new institutions including tax and social security systems and the Scottish National Investment Bank, and advised the First Minister through the independence and Brexit referenda and on inter-governmental negotiations.
She is now a Specialist Partner at policy consultancy, Flint Global.
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/public_knowledge_pod
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@public_knowledge_pod?_t=8sIhMOiLosj&_r=1
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/publicknowledgepod.bsky.social
Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/public-knowledge-pod/about
Listen to all episodes on Youtube, Spotify and Apple