Podcast Show Summary
Guest Details
Judge Allison Goddard – U.S. Magistrate Judge, Southern District of California
Judge Goddard brings a wealth of experience from both private practice and the judiciary. She has been at the forefront of eDiscovery, AI in litigation, and proportionality in modern discovery. Recently, she collaborated with the Sedona Conference on AI guidance for the judiciary, making her an invaluable voice on legal tech adoption.
Key Takeaways
1️⃣ AI in the Judiciary Is Here to Stay – Courts are exploring how judges can responsibly use Gen AI while maintaining human oversight ("Judge in the Loop"). AI can enhance efficiency, but it requires proper safeguards.
2️⃣ The Evolving Role of AI in Discovery – AI-assisted eDiscovery tools, hyperlinked documents, and bias in search prompts are raising new legal challenges. Attorneys and judges will need to balance efficiency with defensibility in discovery practices.
3️⃣ The Black Box Problem & Legal Trust – While AI tools are powerful, many legal professionals remain skeptical because of lack of transparency and potential bias. The judiciary will likely require expert testimony and case law development to address these concerns.
Action Items
✅ Judges should explore Gen AI responsibly – AI can assist in drafting orders and summarizing briefs but should never replace judicial reasoning.
✅ Lawyers must address AI in Rule 26 Conferences – Expect new disputes over AI-generated discovery results and defensibility of prompts.
✅ Stay updated on AI case law & Sedona Guidelines – Courts are actively shaping policies on Gen AI in discovery, confidentiality, and proportionality.
Podcast Chapters & Timecodes
🕒 00:00 – Introduction: Welcoming Judge Allison Goddard and her work in AI & eDiscovery.
🕒 02:13 – AI in the Judiciary: How the Sedona Conference guidelines shape AI use for judges.
🕒 10:46 – The Complacency Risk: AI tools are getting better, but judges & lawyers must avoid over-reliance.
🕒 19:07 – AI in Drafting & Decision Making: How Gen AI enhances efficiency while preserving human judgment.
🕒 28:48 – AI in eDiscovery: A New TAR Battle?: The next legal fights will likely center around AI-generated search results & bias in prompts.
🕒 37:28 – Show Me Your Prompt!: Will courts begin demanding AI prompt transparency in discovery disputes?
🕒 45:10 – The Future of AI in Law: How AI could reduce bias in judicial decisions and reshape legal practice.
🔔 Don’t forget to subscribe to the NeLI Podcast for more expert insights on legal technology, AI, and e-discovery!
🎙 Follow Us: