In this episode, the hosts explore one of the most infamous and controversial criminal-justice stories in U.S. history: the 1993 murders of three eight-year-old boys in West Memphis, Arkansas. # teens were charged. This is the trial of Jesse Misskelley.

CareyOn Productions

Sam and AJ continue the dive into the trial of the West Memphis 3 in this part 2 of an "I don't know how long this will take" series.They discuss the investigation's missteps, the societal context of the time, including the satanic panic, and the implications of police errors in the case. The conversation highlights the complexities of the justice system and the impact of public perception on the accused.

CareyOn Production

In this episode, AJ Carey and Sam Rossi delve into the tragic case of the West Memphis Three, focusing on the murder of three young boys in 1993 and the wrongful conviction of three teenagers. They discuss the investigation's missteps, the societal context of the time, including the satanic panic, and the implications of police errors in the case. The conversation highlights the complexities of the justice system and the impact of public perception on the accused.

CareyOn Productions

This conversation delves into the life and tragic murder of Mia Zapata, the lead singer of the punk rock band The Gits. The hosts discuss her early life, musical journey, the circumstances surrounding her murder, the investigation that followed, and the broader implications of violence against women in society. Through humor and poignant reflections, they highlight the impact of Mia's story on the music community and the ongoing issues of violence against women.

CareyOn Productions

This conversation delves into the intriguing case of John Burgess, a mastermind who attempted to extort a casino using a complex bomb. The discussion covers his background, the planning and execution of the bombing, the subsequent investigation, and the eventual consequences faced by Burgess and his accomplices. The hosts reflect on the absurdity of the crime and the familial betrayals that ensued, providing a mix of humor and serious commentary on the events.

CareyOn Productions

This conversation delves into the true crime story of Pauline Parker and Juliet Hulmes, whose intense friendship led to the murder of Parker's mother. The discussion explores their backgrounds, the crime itself, the subsequent trial, and the impact of the film adaptation 'Heavenly Creatures'. The hosts reflect on themes of friendship, obsession, and the psychological factors that can lead to violence among youth.

CareyOn Productions

The conversation delves into the tragic story of Henrik Siwiak, an immigrant who was murdered in New York City on the night of September 11, 2001. The hosts discuss the complexities surrounding his death, the challenges faced by law enforcement in the aftermath of the terrorist attacks, and the broader implications of violence and crime in a city reeling from tragedy. They reflect on the immigrant experience, the nature of murder investigations, and the societal responses to crime in the context of larger events.

CareyOn Productions

We delve into the infamous Tylenol murders of 1983, where several individuals died after consuming cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules. We discuss the investigation that followed, the suspects, and the significant changes in pharmaceutical regulations that resulted from this case. They also touch on the cultural impact of the murders and the ongoing mystery surrounding the identity of the perpetrator.

CareyOn Productions

Sam makes AJ delve into the life of Geraldine Elizabeth Carmichael, a con artist who became infamous for her fraudulent automotive company, the 20th Century Motor Car Corporation. The siblings discuss her background, her multiple marriages, her criminal activities, and the eventual revelation of her identity on the show Unsolved Mysteries. They reflect on the nature of white-collar crime and the societal implications of such cons, particularly focusing on the automotive industry and the need for affordable vehicles.

CareyOn Production

Sam and AJ delves into the life and crimes of John Spano, a businessman who attempted to purchase the New York Islanders hockey team through fraudulent means. They explore Spano's background, his failed business ventures, the unraveling of his fraudulent deal, and the legal consequences he faced. They reflect on the implications of his actions and the broader themes of white-collar crime in the sports industry. 

CareyOn Productions

In this episode, Sam and AJ explore the chilling case of Sean Sellers, who was executed for crimes committed as a minor. The discussion delves into the legal and ethical complexities of the death penalty for juveniles, examining Sellers' background, his claims of demonic possession, and his conversion to Christianity while on death row. The episode also touches on broader themes of justice, rehabilitation, and the societal implications of capital punishment for young offenders. 

CareyOn Productions

Uncover the eerie tale of the 1928 Hex Murder Case, where superstition and fear led to a shocking crime in rural Pennsylvania. This episode delves into the chilling events and cultural beliefs that fueled a community's descent into chaos. Tune in to explore the intersection of folklore and reality in this gripping true crime story.

In this episode, the hosts engage in light-hearted banter before delving into the tragic story of Grace Mae Brown and her relationship with Chester Gillette, leading to a murder trial that captivated the nation. They explore the details of the case, the societal implications, and the historical context, while also discussing their plans for a road trip to visit significant locations related to the story.



CareyOn Productions

The conversation delves into a local true crime story involving a suspected serial killer, Bernard Hatch, who was implicated in the murder of Mary Rose Turner in 1973. The hosts discuss the details of the crime, the investigation, and the subsequent trial, highlighting the impact on the local community and the historical context surrounding the events. They also touch on urban legends and personal connections to the area, setting the stage for future discussions about local lore and ghost stories.

CareyOn Productions 

This conversation delves into the life and crimes of Mark William Hoffman, a notorious forger who deceived the LDS Church and others with his fabricated historical documents. The discussion covers Hoffman's early life, his rise to infamy through forgery, the bombings he orchestrated, and the legal repercussions he faced. The hosts explore the psychological aspects of Hoffman's actions and the broader implications of his forgeries on historical narratives.



CareyOn Productions

This conversation delves into the life and crimes of Bobby Joe Long, a notorious serial killer from Tampa Bay. The hosts discuss his troubled childhood, the series of abductions and murders he committed, his arrest, trial, and eventual execution. They also reflect on the legal system and the impact of Long's crimes on the victims and their families, particularly focusing on survivor Lisa McVeigh's journey.

This conversation explores the economic struggles and civil unrest in post-revolutionary America, particularly focusing on the events leading to Shays' Rebellion. The discussion highlights the fragility of the new republic and draws parallels to modern protests, emphasizing the importance of diverse strategies in civil unrest. The speakers reflect on the role of government in these events and the historical context that shapes current societal issues.

The conversation delves into the Lager Beer Riot of 1855 in Chicago, exploring the political climate, the role of immigrants, and the consequences of the crackdown on alcohol. The hosts discuss the historical significance of the riot as a form of civil disobedience against oppressive laws and reflect on the ongoing relevance of these themes in contemporary society.

HEY Y'ALL!!!! Happy Friday!!! Sam decided to release some of the theme songs that made the cut before we decided to have the one we have. 

CareyOn Productions

This conversation delves into the historical context and events surrounding the 1900 New Orleans riot, exploring the racial tensions that led to violence and the role of law enforcement. The speakers reflect on the implications of racially motivated laws and the ongoing issues of prejudice and violence in society.