Part 1

 On election night 2008, motel owner, Sabine Musil-Buehler seemingly vanished without a trace from the quiet beach town of Anna Maria Island, Florida. Immediately, the town speculated her that either her estranged husband or her new boyfriend were to blame. It wasn’t until seven years after her assumed murder, that her skeletal remains were found after a confession from her killer. In this episode, Brooke discusses her trip to the island, and her late night photo session at Ms. Musil Buehler’s unfortunate gravesite. 

Part 2 

Treated as an outcast by his mother who didn’t want a second son, Jerry Brudos was humiliated as a child by being forced to dress up in girl’s clothing at an early age and berated about sexuality and all that it entailed. Did Brudos’ “mommy issues” lead him to be a sadistic killer with a woman’s shoe fetish?