In this episode of Fire Away, Rabbi Shoff delves into one of the hardest questions in Jewish thought: If God is good, why is there so much suffering, including tragedies like the Holocaust? He explores the difference between intellectual and emotional pain, the limits of human understanding, and the Torah’s view on why hardship can lead to growth.
Watch the video version of this podcast on Meaningful Minute Plus at https://mmplus.org
What’s really behind the divide between the Israeli army and the yeshiva world?
In this powerful first episode, Rabbi Shoff dives deep into one of the most emotional and complex questions facing the Jewish people today: Why do some fight in the army while others stay in yeshiva?
He explores both perspectives — the soldiers’ sacrifice and the Torah learners’ devotion — with honesty, empathy, and depth. This is not a debate; it’s an invitation to understanding, unity, and compassion among Am Yisrael.
🎧 Listen as we unpack:
👉 Watch now and join the conversation.
Send us your thoughts and questions at FireAway.plus
No question is too small. No topic is too big.
Every week, Rabbi Elchanan Shoff steps into the fire—answering the questions people are really asking. Torah and halacha. Life and relationships. Meaning, morality, and the struggles of being Jewish in today’s world. And much more.
Your questions on anything Judaism. Plus, the myths and lies about our faith—debunked with clarity and truth.
This is not just another Q&A. This is Fire Away—where the hardest questions ignite the deepest answers.
You can send questions in via speakpipe.com/meaningfulminute or email them to eitan@meaningfulminute.org