This is the story of how a Christian minister became Jewish—and why it felt like coming home.
In this deeply personal and moving episode, listeners are invited into the extraordinary journey of Eleanor Harrison Bregman—a Christian minister from Savannah, Georgia—whose decades-long interfaith marriage, commitment to raising Jewish children, and deep engagement with Jewish community life ultimately led her to Orthodox conversion. This is not just a story of religion, but of love, identity, and the courage to step fully into a place where the heart has long lived.
Eleanor shares how her path wound from seminary classrooms to synagogue leadership, from Christmas traditions to Shabbat tables, and how world events—including the shock of October 7th—crystallized a truth she had been living for years. Listeners will hear about the emotional complexity of interfaith family life, the quiet accumulation of spiritual shifts, and the profound sense of belonging that comes when one’s inner reality finally meets public affirmation.
Key Takeaways
Timestamps
[00:00] Follow your own heart in interfaith relationships
[01:58] Eleanor’s upbringing in Savannah and path to New York
[04:04] Deciding to raise Jewish children while in ministry
[07:00] Family reactions to Orthodox conversion of children
[10:34] Navigating faith and identity after children are born
[19:00] Starting “Strangers No More” for interfaith couples
[27:45] Moving from B’nai Jeshurun community life
[34:17] Windham’s role during COVID in deepening Jewish connection
[39:00] October 7th and realizing “I was Jewish from the inside out”
[44:10] Mikvah, wedding celebration, and feeling true belonging
Links