We might look like holy people, but we weren't born this way. In this deeply personal episode of the Trusting God Podcast, Father Bennett shares his powerful conversion story—a journey that took him from being an unbaptized 21-year-old college student to a Catholic priest.Discover the crucial role a Catholic school education played in planting a seed of faith, the teenage struggles of seeking answers in a secular world, and the pivotal moment before a crucifix at Midnight Mass that changed everything. Father Bennett walks us through his decision to finally call the church, his experience in RCIA, and the profound peace he found in the faith, especially in the wake of 9/11.This episode is a testament to the truth that conversion is not a one-time event, but a lifelong process of trusting God, being open to His formation, and actively participating in the life of the Church. It's an encouraging message for anyone who feels lost, is afraid to ask questions, or is a parent wondering how to pass on the faith.Timestamps:00:00:05 - Introduction: We Weren't Born This Way02:25:15 - A Priest's Backstory: Unbaptized Until Age 2105:49:09 - The Teenage Struggle & A Longing for Faith13:36:14 - The College Years: Seeing Faith in Action21:30:20 - The Turning Point: A Pivotal Midnight Mass Experience26:23:12 - God's Promise: Seek and You Will Find33:10:08 - Why Conversion is a Lifelong Process44:53:22 - The "Both/And" of Catholic Faith: Belief and Practice51:12:10 - Your Call to Action: Be Proactive in Your FaithFor more information about St. Michael the Archangel Pastorate, visit:🌐 Website: https://stmichaelpastorate.org/📱 Facebook (St. Augustine, Rensselaer): https://www.facebook.com/staugustinerensselaer📱 Facebook (Sacred Heart, Remington): https://www.facebook.com/sacredheartremington📷 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stmichaelpastorate/🎥 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@st.michaelthearchangelpast999🟣 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/trust-in-god-podcast/id1845406973 🟢 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7f6OQsJ3gD8mNAZqMyMLaW?si=312994efcd894cff We’re excited to grow with you!