In this extra-long episode of This Ends Your Time on The Challenge, we dive deep into The Challenge: Season 41, Episode 3. We break down the intense, water-fueled challenge where contestants feel like they were about to die. We talk about why these new Threats are shaking up the game, how Cara’s hilarious alter ego “Carl” had us in stitches, and our best unsolicited tips for the MTV producers.

We also dissect Olivia’s puzzling strategy (and her manipulation of Justin), Yeremi’s undeniable power, and which rookies are already giving Vet energy—while some Vets are strangely playing like Threats. Plus, Bananas declaring “I am the f***ing Challenge!” has us questioning if he’s living rent-free in his own head.

We cover Nia’s unfortunate knee injury, America being voted into elimination, and the twist of Nia being disqualified, setting the stage for America’s possible return to the Arena.