One week Pep is a genius. The next he’s “overthinking.” The same tactic is either revolutionary or reckless depending on the result. This is punditry in 2025; outcome bias, tribal narratives, and entertainment over explanation.

We unpack:

- Why Amorim gets slammed for the same system Pep gets praised for

- How pundits flip-flop to feed the attention economy

- Why modern punditry blurs into fandom and banter

- How fans can cut through the noise and find real analysis

#FootballPundits, #SoccerAnalysis, #PremierLeague, #HotTakes, #FootballPodcast, #SportsMedia, #PepGuardiola, #ManchesterUnited, #Amorim, #SkySports, #TacticalAnalysis, #FootballFans

Subscribe to our channels and enjoy this episode:

YouTube: / @theshaftpodcasts. .

Spotify: https://spotify.link/oHwF5hicHDb

Appreciations for this Episode:

Host: Andy Terku

Video Production: Andrews Terkpertey

Video Editing: Samuel Okuadjo

Timestamps:

00:00 – 05:36 | The Flip-Flop of Football Punditry

05:37 – 11:12 | Incentives and Hot Takes

11:13 – 13:09 | Complexity and Independent Thinking