In 1976, residents of the small town of Circleville, Ohio began receiving disturbing anonymous letters—each one filled with personal threats, secrets, and accusations. What started as a handful of notes quickly escalated into a decades-long mystery involving a suspicious death, a bizarre booby trap, a controversial conviction, and one chilling question that still haunts the community: Who was writing the letters? In this episode of The Midnight Report, we unravel one of the most bizarre and ...
All content for The Midnight Report is the property of Mikey Stone and is served directly from their servers
with no modification, redirects, or rehosting. The podcast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Podjoint in any way.
In 1976, residents of the small town of Circleville, Ohio began receiving disturbing anonymous letters—each one filled with personal threats, secrets, and accusations. What started as a handful of notes quickly escalated into a decades-long mystery involving a suspicious death, a bizarre booby trap, a controversial conviction, and one chilling question that still haunts the community: Who was writing the letters? In this episode of The Midnight Report, we unravel one of the most bizarre and ...
Poison To The Pen: Who Really Wrote The Circleville Letters?
The Midnight Report
27 minutes
3 months ago
Poison To The Pen: Who Really Wrote The Circleville Letters?
In 1976, residents of the small town of Circleville, Ohio began receiving disturbing anonymous letters—each one filled with personal threats, secrets, and accusations. What started as a handful of notes quickly escalated into a decades-long mystery involving a suspicious death, a bizarre booby trap, a controversial conviction, and one chilling question that still haunts the community: Who was writing the letters? In this episode of The Midnight Report, we unravel one of the most bizarre and ...
The Midnight Report
In 1976, residents of the small town of Circleville, Ohio began receiving disturbing anonymous letters—each one filled with personal threats, secrets, and accusations. What started as a handful of notes quickly escalated into a decades-long mystery involving a suspicious death, a bizarre booby trap, a controversial conviction, and one chilling question that still haunts the community: Who was writing the letters? In this episode of The Midnight Report, we unravel one of the most bizarre and ...
