In late 1944, Greece stood at a crossroads. The Nazi occupiers were gone, leaving behind a power vacuum dominated by the colossal Communist-led resistance, EAM-ELAS. With three-quarters of a million members and a powerful army, they seemed poised for victory. Yet, within a year, their movement was politically shattered and militarily defeated, setting the stage for a brutal civil war. How could such a dominant force be so completely vanquished?

This is the central question explored in today's debate, revealing two powerful and conflicting narratives. Was this a story of geopolitical betrayal? Evidence points to the secret "Percentages Agreement" where Churchill and Stalin placed Greece firmly in the Western sphere, effectively sacrificing the Greek communists on the altar of Great Power politics. This was brutally enforced by Britain, first through political manipulation and then with tanks and aircraft during the bloody "Dekemvriana" in Athens. From this perspective, the resistance was an outmatched pawn on a global chessboard.

Or was it a tragedy of internal failure? This argument holds the KKE leadership accountable for a series of catastrophic errors. Paralyzed by caution and adherence to Moscow's line, they delayed forming their own alternative government—unlike the successful Tito in Yugoslavia—and made fatal concessions by joining a unity government without securing real power. They agreed to a disarmament process that left their enemies armed while neutralizing their own forces. This strategic indecisiveness, it is argued, handed their powerful external and internal foes the very tools needed to orchestrate their destruction. Understanding this pivotal moment requires grappling with both the crushing weight of foreign intervention and the critical, squandered opportunities of the resistance itself.

Source: Nikolaos Stelya, Sintrofoi: Yunanistan’da Komünizm Rüyası: Yunanistan Komünist Partisi (KKE) Tarihi (1918-1949) (Comrades: The Dream of Communism in Greece: History of the Communist Party of Greece (KKE) (1918-1949)) (Istanbul: Kalkedon Yayınları, 2025).