In our very first true crime deep dive, we take on the heartbreaking and haunting case of the four University of Idaho students murdered in their home in November 2022. This case has stuck with us — maybe because it feels like every woman’s worst nightmare. We walk through what happened, how the suspect was tracked down and arrested, and we share our own thoughts on what may have led to these senseless killings.

While there was a moment we couldn’t help but laugh (thanks to Melli tripping over her words), our hearts remain with the victims — Kaylee, Madison, Xana, and Ethan — and their families. We will not name the killer in this episode, because the story should be about the lives lost, not the monster who took them.