Neil Young vs. Chrome Hearts — What happens when a rock legend collides with a luxury fashion powerhouse? Chrome Hearts has filed suit against Neil Young, claiming his new band “Neil Young and the Chrome Hearts” infringes on their famous trademark

 


On this episode of The Briefing, Weintraub attorneys Scott Hervey and James Kachmar unpack the lawsuit, analyze the likelihood of confusion, and compare it to the Lady Gaga “Mayhem” case. Plus, they share practical takeaways for musicians to avoid trademark trouble.




Show Notes: 

 

Scott:  Neil Young, one of the most influential voices in rock history, has landed in federal court, but not for his music. His new backing band, Neil Young and the Chrome Hearts, has become the center of a trademark infringement lawsuit filed by luxury fashion brand, Chrome Hearts. At issue is whether Neil Young's use of the Chrome Hearts' name, and especially the sale of related merchandise, crossed the line into infringement. I'm Scott Hervey, a partner of the I'm a law firm of Weintraub Tobin, and today I'm joined by my partner, James Kachmar. We are going to break down Chrome Hearts versus Neil Young on today's installment of The Briefing.

 

James, welcome back to The Briefing. Good to have you.

 

James:  Thanks for having me, Scott. Anytime you've got a clash between a rock legend and a fashion powerhouse, you know it's going to be an interesting case.

Scott:  Oh, absolutely. Well, so let's set the stage, shall we? So Chrome Hearts filed suit in the Central District of California against Neil Young and his production company, the Other Shoe Productions, and his bandmates. The complaint alleges trademark infringement, false designation of origin, unfair competition, common law trademark infringement, and common law unfair competition. But I think the centerpiece of this case really is the federal trademark infringement claim. I think, really, this case either lives or dies on whether or not Neil Young has violated the Lanham Act. Okay, let's talk about some background here. Chrome Hearts, for those of you who aren't aware, Chrome Hearts is not just a boutique clothing line. It's a billion-dollar brand that's been around since 1988. They've built an empire on jewelry, leather goods, apparel, eyewear, and even furniture. They've collaborated with the Rolling Stones, Rihanna, Madonna, Drake, and countless others. Their products are sold in exclusive boutiques worldwide, and they have a loyal following among musicians and celebrities. Now, critically, Chrome Hearts has a very long list of federally-registered trademarks covering Chrome Hearts, both the wordmark and related designs. These registrations span across jewelry, letter goods, clothing, eyewear, retail store services, and even entertainment services in the nature of live performances by a musical band.

 

Now, that last one is particularly important because I think it directly overlaps with Neil Young's activities.

 

James:  I knew about Chrome Hearts as a fashion and jewelry brand, but I had no idea that there was a band associated with it. Did you know that, Scott?

 

Scott:  No, I didn't until I read the complaint. I got a little curious, and I found the specific trademark that covered their entertainment services. I mean, it's listed in the complaint. I looked up its file at the USPTO to see what specimens it submitted. Lo and behold, it's a photo of a band with the band name Chrome Hearts right there on the stage monitors.