As Mr. and Mrs. McGills’ relationship unravels, Stacey finds herself caught in the fray and, after several failed attempts to Parent Trap her mom and dad into reconciling, confronts a big decision: should she stay in New York in her father’s pre-war bachelor pad, or leave the city yet again to live with her mother in Stoneybrook suburbia? 

Pile into the backseat of the McGill’s station wagon with us (and Claudia) as we house-hunt and spend some time in the mind of America’s Favorite Baby-sitter (as of 1989) in Welcome Back, Stacey! (What a tell-all title.)

As mentioned on this episode:

How we picture Laine (Elizabeth Perkins in Big (1988))

Another gal we love with a taxi cab wardrobe palette 

The Brave Little Toaster (1987)

Did you ever decline an Oreo and braid hair instead at a sleepover? Tell us at stoneybrookreunion@gmail.com.

Find us (and a picture of the much-discussed cover) on Instagram @stoneybrookreunion.