So what really happened to Judy MacFarlane? In the final episode, Hailey finds untouched information about the end of Judy's life.

Judy MacFarlane was arguably the reason Bobby Norris spent close to two years in prison; he was released the day after she was last seen alive. Detective Allen and Bobby's former partner dig into the strongest suspect in this case.

The last person to see Judy MacFarlane alive tells Detective Allen a new version of that night, and the detective digs deeper into his troubled past.

When Judy MacFarlane was murdered, most of her family suspected her estranged husband, Jim. From his drug cartel ties to the state of the marriage, Detective Kevin Allen seems to be the first to examine the husband.

When Judy MacFarlane's body is found, detectives have more questions than answers. To this day, no one is certain how she could have ended up in a retention pond inside a locked, barbed wire fence and the theories are almost too crazy to believe.

In the midst of Gainesville, Florida's darkest chapter, Judy MacFarlane disappears after her Bible study. The town has been turned upside down for its many missing or murdered college students, but Judy's case seems to be different and her family and local law enforcement publicly argue over whether something bad happened to her or she left on purpose.

Journalist Hailey Holloway heads back to Gainesville, Florida to dig into the mysterious murder of Judy MacFarlane. Judy's inexplicable death was one of the strangest cases of her time, but it was buried and long-forgotten. Hailey is teaming up with the first detective to re-open the case since Judy's death in 1992 to try and figure out what happened to the young mother of four, why her murder seems to have been pushed aside, and sort through the complicated list of who may have been responsible. 

In August of 1990, the Gainesville Ripper struck the small college town of Gainesville, Florida. He murdered five students over a weekend, terrorizing the community for months and changing the state's law enforcement forever.

Hailey heads back to Gainesville to search ”The Spot” with Detective Allen and a cadaver search dog in what may be the last physical search for Tiffany Sessions.

Hailey and Detective Kevin Allen go through the original tips from the 1989 Tiffany Sessions hotline, and then go inside the current search for the missing UF student.

A possible witness from the 1989 kidnapping of Tiffany Sessions comes forward to tell her story.

Detective Kevin Allen pieces the case together, finally connecting Paul Rowles' victims, and starting a new search for Tiffany Sessions.

Paul Rowles kidnapped a 15 year old girl and drove her across Florida. She escaped and in this episode you can hear her tell her own story for the first time.

College students were found murdered in Gainesville one after another, after another, after another. Hailey digs into Gainesville's darkest years with the original detectives.

Tiffany Sessions went out for a walk in 1989 and was never seen again. Her parents, college roommate, and the original detectives walk us through one of the biggest missing persons searches in Florida history.

After years of stalking women, Paul Rowles gives in to his desires. In this episode, the original detective, prosecutors and the victim's husband walk us through the first case.

Shallow Graves is a podcast about a serial killer you’ve never heard of. He slipped under the radar for years and because of that, one of his victims has been missing for 31 years, and everyone familiar with the case believes there must be more victims. Shallow Graves digs into the details of each case by talking to the original detectives and family members, and bringing you inside the case as it stands today.