This panel discussion reflects on the challenges of Scottish devolution and the relationship with the rest of the UK. Issues surrounding Scotland’s constitutional future continue to dominate and polarise Scottish politics and political debate. But the contested nature of the process – and especially the question of whether or not there could or should be an independence referendum – has crowded out meaningful discussion of the challenges facing devolution and Scotland’s relationship with the rest of the UK.  To explore some of these challenges, the RSE is partnering with the UK in a Changing Europe, as well as the Institute for Government and Bennett Institute for Public Policy, University of Cambridge, as part of their review of the UK constitution, to host a panel discussion with key experts and commentators.    This session is chaired by Kenny Farquharson, Columnist and Senior Writer for The Times. Panel includes: Professor Michael Keating FRSEGeneral Secretary, RSE Professor Ailsa Henderson FRSEProfessor of Political Science, University of Edinburgh Jess SargeantSenior Researcher, Institute for Government Dr Philip Rycrof FRSEFormer senior Cabinet Office official