John Piper makes a compelling argument that there is no necessary contradiction between deep emotion, often referred to as "fire" or "passion," and structured forms of expression. He metaphorically describes emotions as a "river flowing out of one’s heart" and form as "the riverbanks." Crucially, he states that "without [riverbanks] the river runs shallow and dissipates on the plain," but "banks make the river run deep," meaning form provides the structure for emotions to achieve profundity and impact.

Piper illustrates this by highlighting the book of Lamentations. Despite being a "deeply emotional book" filled with agony and intense fervor, it is also "the most formally crafted book in the Old Testament," featuring intricate acrostic structures. This exemplifies how "genuine, heartfelt expression of our deepest emotions does not require spontaneity."

While acknowledging the "danger of formalism" leading to stiff or artificial expressions, he cautions that the "danger of spontaneity is also great" if the heart lacks true passion, resulting in "lifeless, jargon-laden" communication. The core issue, according to Piper, is a "dry spring" in the heart—a lack of genuine passion—not the form itself. He contends that "formed affection often strikes deeper" and reveals more profound emotional depths than raw, unstudied spontaneity.

Ultimately, Piper advocates for "deep feelings in worthy forms from God-besotted hearts and minds," urging for authentic passion expressed through disciplined and meaningful means, distinguishing it from superficial emotionalism.

Reformed Theologian GPT: https://chat.openai.com/g/g-XXwzX1gnv-reformed-theologian

https://buymeacoffee.com/edi2730