Chapters

[00:00:00] Intro Song — Cold Open Poem & Host Intros

[00:01:00] Blue Ridge setup, Part I callback, what’s coming

[00:02:00] Local Legends: Toccoa calaboose, Toccoa Falls, Rabun Bald, Downtown Blue Ridge

[00:06:00] Tales from the Shadows I — Madeline (bedside woman, moss man, toddler-in-bed)

[00:11:00] Tales from the Shadows II — Stony Brook lab → “Seatbelt Psychic” arc

[00:16:00] Winchester Mystery House (on Sarah Winchester’s death day) + gift shop

[00:18:00] GA/Houdini tangent & Christian Day cameo

[00:21:00] Easy-riser stairs, switchbacks, tight “pony wall” stairwells

[00:23:00] Quake-damaged wing & Witch’s Cap acoustics

[00:26:00] The window that closed itself (protective nudge?)

[00:29:00] Group reactions & Sarah-to-Sarah moment

[00:30:00] Reading the Tea: Conjuring House Halloween auction (foreclosure/zoning)

[00:33:00] Legal/disclosure chat & attorney call-out (Shadow Chat invite)

[00:36:00] Warrens estate moves, Annabelle on tour, Conjuring box office, Will Zak bid?

[00:39:00] Rife vs. Bagans? Road-trip season speculation

[00:40:00] Conjuring Universe lore: Sister Irene/Lorraine theory

[00:41:00] Tea wrap → segue to LORE by LOR

[00:42:00] LORE by LOR: Bloody Mary (setup & Mary Tudor aside)

[00:46:00] Bloody Mary/Mary Worth village tale

[00:50:00] Mirror ritual & source shout

[00:51:00] This Month’s Pour: “Chicken wine” rosé review

[00:52:00] Ratings & toast

[00:53:00] Sign-off & Poppy button

Episode description

Paranormal Playback — R&R Sept Part 2

Hosts: Charlie, Lor, and Mel

Shadow People, pull up a chair—this month’s bonus banter goes full campfire in Georgia’s Blue Ridge. We hit cemeteries, tiny jails (yes, a calaboose), a haunted church, and a maybe-protective moment at the Winchester Mystery House—on Sarah Winchester’s death day.

We open with local lore (Toccoa’s fiery calaboose tale, Toccoa Falls spirits, demon-people rumors on Rabun Bald, downtown Blue Ridge ghost walks) and then dive into Tales from the Shadows:

• Madeline (Baton Rouge): a shadowed woman in a white nightgown at the foot of her bed, a moss-draped “green man,” and years later the tiny-footstep, toddler-in-bed experience.

• John Ryan (Stony Brook): a lab volunteer, an alleged equipment scam, a campus sting—then a pivot to celebrity medium fame and Seatbelt Psychic. Con? Coincidence? Cinematic universe?

Charlie tours the Winchester Mystery House: switchback staircases, the echo-tricky Witch’s Cap, and a window that closed the instant she raised her camera. Wind or mechanism—or a gentle “hey, you’re pregnant—step back” from Sarah to Sarah?

In Reading the Tea, Lor breaks down the Conjuring House’s Halloween mortgage-foreclosure auction, the Warrens estate shuffle (Matt Rife, Annabelle on the road), and whether a certain museum owner with well-timed emojis might bid. Rivalry brewing? Popcorn ready.

We close with LORE by LOR: Bloody Mary—sleepover mirrors, Mary Tudor side-notes, and the gnarlier village tale—then a quick review of our beloved “chicken wine” rosé. Dry, fresh finish, long legs, zero notes of demon people.

Got a story or want a Shadow Chat?

Email: paranormallaybackpod@gmail.com

Send a voice memo or use the contact form on our site.

If you enjoy the show, follow/subscribe/rate on Apple & Spotify—your reviews help other spooky nerds find us.

Content notes: child/ghost themes; historical death; light profanity; alleged scams.

Paranormal Playback is your weekly deep dive into spooky reality TV, ghost hunts, dramatic reenactments, and enough EVP to raise the dead. Hosted by Charlie Holley, Melanie Malone, & Lauren Sanders.

Each episode has its own gallery on our website to explore while you listen.

Leave Us a Ghost Story:

→ Instgram @paranormalplayback

→ TikTok @paranormal.playba

→ ☎️ VM: (404) 981-4533

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.