Jeff’s living every shopper’s dream - his package got sent to the wrong house, the company re-shipped it, and then the neighbor brought the original back. So now he has two. Is it a blessing or low-key stealing if he keeps them both?

Meanwhile, Rachael is ditching social media and cozying up with the most random lineup of ‘90s TV nostalgia - Empty Nest, Parker Lewis Can’t Lose, and Dinosaurs.

Jeff takes a trip down memory lane at his old high school and is suddenly wondering how to land himself in the Hall of Fame. (Do we start a petition? We think so.)

And of course, we put our friendship to the test again with another round of Do Your Co-Hosts Even Know Each Other?