A quiet beach on the Sonoma Coast. Two sleeping bags in the sand. And a crime so brutal, it would leave a permanent scar on a small California town.

In August 2004, Lindsay Cutshall and Jason Allen—young, devout, and deeply in love—set out for a weekend getaway. By morning, they were gone, executed while they slept beside the Pacific Ocean. No witnesses. No motive. No answers.

For thirteen years, their case remained unsolved—until a second murder shattered the silence and exposed a killer who had been hiding in plain sight.

This is the haunting story of the Jenner Beach Murders—an investigation marked by dead ends, a community gripped by fear, and families whose grief would change lives in unexpected ways.

From Northern Crimes, this is one of the most chilling cases we’ve ever covered.

Subscribe to Northern Crimes on YouTube.

Join the Northern Crimes community on Patreon!

🔍Sources can be found at NorthernCrimes.com

If you enjoy Northern Crimes please give us a review and leave a comment!