In 2001, the small town of West Helena, Arkansas was shaken by the brutal murder of Carlaretta Knowlton — a young Black woman whose life was cut short by the man who claimed to love her. Elbert Holder thought he could play the part of devoted partner while hiding a sinister side, but when the truth came out, it exposed a web of lies, betrayal, and violence that ended in tragedy.
This week, T & Willie dig deep into the case, dragging Elbert’s raggedy self to the pits of hell where he belongs. From the twisted relationship dynamics to the courtroom fallout, we unpack how another Black woman’s life was stolen at the hands of a man who was supposed to protect her.
Because here at Melanin Mysteries, we don’t just tell the story — we call it out for what it is.
BTCC Presents: Crime Cocktails & Canvases
10/18/25 Atlanta, Ga - grab your tix here: https://btcc-presents-crime-cocktails-canvases.cheddarup.com/ **TICKET SALES CLOSE 10/1**
Group Room Block Homewood Suites by Hilton
915 Crestline Pkwy, Atlanta, GA 30328 (770) 415-3200 use code: BTCC for discountKeep up with us on social media!
FB, TikTok & IG Melanin Mysteries Podcast
FB group: Love Lies & Alibis Melanin Mysteries Podcast
Ad Space, Merch and Tipping to show your support: MelaninMysteries.com
If you are enjoying, please leave us a 5 star review wherever you listen! That is the BEST way to support the show!