The narrative that Charlie Kirk was muzzled by Jewish donors does not hold up. What seems most plausible is that some supporters walked away when Turning Point USA elevated Tucker Carlson, who has repeatedly trafficked in antisemitic tropes—recasting Jewish Bush-era advisers as “Israelis” and reviving dual-loyalty conspiracies. This was not censorship but a free-market decision about where philanthropic dollars should flow. Kirk was never prevented from speaking; the shift was simply in which donors were willing to fund platforms that risk normalizing antisemitism.