Opening: The Generative TrapMicrosoft’s Generative Pages look like the final, glorious victory for low‑code—the moment the spreadsheet crowd finally caught up to the coders. You type a sentence, press enter, and GPT‑5 obediently assembles a working React page that talks to Dataverse, decorates itself with orange flair, and politely runs on first try. Cue applause, confetti, and a brief illusion that we’ve transcended the need for developers entirely.Yes, it looks effortless. A user describes a dashboard, and within seconds the app agent conjures data grids, filters, even export buttons. Text becomes React. And because it’s built right inside Power Apps, it feels safe—regulated, sandboxed, like the rest of the platform. What could possibly go wrong?Everything.That tidy UI hides the quiet click of a lock disengaging. The magical instant when you whisper, “Edit Code,” and the platform hands you the keys—plus the entire mortgage. Each regenerated line of JSX isn’t a convenience; it’s a liability you now own. A Trojan Horse dressed in productivity, wheeled straight past governance and security review.The promise is autonomy. The price is maintenance. You didn’t hire a developer; you became one, minus the salary and version‑control habits.Here’s the absurd part: someone decided that giving citizen makers direct React access was empowerment. Apparently, years of runaway Excel macros and untested Power Fx formulas didn’t teach us enough humility. So Microsoft wrapped this chaos in pastel branding, stamped it “generative AI,” and declared it progress.Generative Pages whisper, “Don’t worry, the agent will handle it.” It won’t. The agent writes convincing React, not sustainable architecture. Every tweak creates divergence from the low‑code core—the same core that once safeguarded you from dependency hell, npm drift, and patch roulette.You think you got a shortcut. What you actually got was responsibility.Section 1: The Promise and the PivotOfficially, Microsoft calls this a bridge—a seamless link between low‑code convenience and pro‑code flexibility. In theory, GPT‑5 inside Power Apps is the final layer of the stack that lets business users dream in sentences instead of scripting languages. Type “Build a page that lists internal users with filters,” and a capable AI architect assembles the page automatically. Files materialize, components wire themselves up, and the illusion of mastery begins.But here’s where the bridge analogy collapses. This isn’t a bridge; it’s an autopilot that starts rewiring the airplane mid‑flight. You may believe you’re cruising comfortably between low‑code and custom dev. In fact, the AI quietly tears down the cockpit controls and sells you a soldering iron.The intent is noble. Microsoft’s ecosystem has always danced between citizen makers and professional devs. The company wants both populations to coexist, sharing Dataverse tables and governance policies. Generative AI, they argue, finally levels that divide—because now anyone can issue natural‑language commands and get production‑ready code.Except “production‑ready” implies someone, somewhere, will maintain it. And that’s the catch. Low‑code worked because it was declarative—rules, configurations, and formulas that Microsoft’s engine could interpret, validate, and patch safely. Type a formula wrong, and you got a friendly error toast. Edit React? You get lint errors, broken imports, and a vacation into Stack Overflow threads last updated in 2019.This is the moment the promise pivots. The interface still looks like Power Apps, but the guts have left the building. Once that “Edit Code” button is pressed, your app is no longer a managed configuration—it’s source code. The platform stops enforcing its clean boundaries. Identity, data access, control logic, styling—all become mutable text. Text you now have to secure, diff, and patch yourself.Think of Power Apps as a managed city. Roads are paved, lights synchronized, sanitation handled nightly. Everyone...
Show more...