PETA on Why No-Kill is Failing Animals (Episode 287)

https://is1-ssl.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Podcasts221/v4/16/9c/3a/169c3af4-fa82-39aa-59b7-8a5f66cf4a61/mza_17087276821203060059.jpg/600x600bb.jpg

Keep it Humane

262 episodes

1 day ago

Welcome to Keep it Humane: The Podcast (formerly The Animal Control Report)! Hosts Daniel Ettinger, Ashley Bishop, and Ashlee Bishop explore the full spectrum of animal welfare from animal control officers, animal shelters and rescue to advocacy, policy, and community care. We share real stories, expert insights, and conversations that reshape how we talk about helping animals. Whether you're in the industry or simply care about animals, join us as we build understanding and Help People!

Society & Culture

RSS

All content for Keep it Humane is the property of Keep it Humane and is served directly from their servers with no modification, redirects, or rehosting. The podcast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Podjoint in any way.

Society & Culture

https://d3t3ozftmdmh3i.cloudfront.net/staging/podcast_uploaded_nologo/1980811/1980811-1723394857191-2cc96097f576c.jpg

PETA on Why No-Kill is Failing Animals (Episode 287)

Keep it Humane

31 minutes 17 seconds

1 month ago

PETA on Why No-Kill is Failing Animals (Episode 287)

In this episode, we welcome Rachel Bellis from PETA to discuss the organization’s provocative new commercial challenging the “No-Kill” shelter movement and why they believe the approach is failing animals. Based on PETA’s recent feature “What Does Best Friends Animal Society’s ‘No-Kill’ Push Mean for Animals?”, we dig into the realities behind the rhetoric. PETA

Rachel walks us through PETA’s critiques:

How “no-kill” policies can lead to shelters refusing to accept animals in need and pushing them back into harm’s way. PETA
Why simply increasing “live release rates” can mislead the public and mask animal suffering. PETA
The consequences of “return to field” programs for cats, and other practices PETA considers misleading euphemisms. PETA
Cases and data PETA cites, including shelters that are reportedly warehousing animals, turning away strays, or overextending adoption criteria in ways that may put animals at risk. PETA

We also explore potential alternatives: what models might actually address animal homelessness, suffering, and overpopulation—without empty promises. Rachel shares what PETA proposes instead: stronger preventative measures (spay/neuter, banning sales by pet shops), transparency in shelter policies, humane euthanasia when absolutely necessary, and accountability. PETA

Whether you support the no-kill movement, are skeptical, or just care about animal welfare, this episode aims to challenge assumptions, bring new data to light, and spark a deeper conversation about what truly helps animals.