What if your rabbi stood on the bimah and told you exactly how to vote? Would it strengthen your faith—or make you walk out the door?

This episode of "In Such a Time: Conversations on Jewish Life, Leadership and Meaning" pulls back the curtain on a heated debate most congregants never witness: To what extent should rabbis use their authority to advocate for political positions from the pulpit? Join Rabbis Jonathan Jaffe and Leora Londy as they bravely lift the lid on their own impassioned disagreements about the role of politics in synagogue life, revealing not only their intellectual differences but also the profound respect that keeps them united in purpose.

Key highlights from the conversation include:

• Honest, behind-the-scenes struggles over whether clergy should speak about political issues like immigration, democracy, and Israel—and the price of silence in divisive times.
• Confessions about the tension between being a prophetic voice for justice and a pastoral presence for community cohesion.
• Real-life stories from the rabbis’ personal lives, including family synagogue choices impacted by politicized sermons and the moral quandaries of advocating for immigration reform or installing solar panels—right down to risking alienation and controversy.
• A mutual reckoning with the privilege and responsibility inherited from Jewish history, and the challenge of applying ancient Torah values to messy, modern issues.
• Reflection on how new platforms like podcasts reshape rabbinic influence and maintain deep connections with the Jewish community, even as the meaning of "speaking from the bima" evolves.

Will the rabbis find common ground, or are some disagreements just too fundamental to bridge? Listen in for a candid, urgent, and deeply personal exploration of what it means to lead—and unite—a community in times when politics can divide us most.

Episode Overview & Timestamps

• [00:00:00] – Intro: Setting the stage for this week's controversial conversation
• [00:01:16] – Rabbi Londy reveals her passion (and frustration) about addressing politics on the bima
• [00:04:41] – Rabbi Jaffe brings humility—and historical perspective—to the debate
• [00:08:38] – The sermons’ purpose: Should rabbis help congregants process current events?
• [00:12:11] – Prophet or pastor: How rabbis juggle the roles of comforter and challenger
• [00:14:03] – Difficult questions: What are truly "Jewish values" in political policy?
• [00:16:11] – Immigration and dignity: Personal stories and Torah wisdom
• [00:19:40] – Means vs. ends: Where shared values lead to political disagreement
• [00:23:05] – To act or just reflect? Why discomfort can be powerful
• [00:25:41] – Volunteerism vs. political activism: Where do synagogues draw the line?
• [00:29:19] – The "elephants in the room": Israel, America, and double standards
• [00:33:54] – The evolving role of the rabbi: From the bima to the podcast
• [00:36:53] – Final reflections: The risks of silence, the value of connection, and an open invitation for listener feedback

Don't miss this episode—it's a rare and thought-provoking look into the moral and practical dilemmas shaping today's American Judaism.