This week, the Hollywood Video Guys dust off the shelves and crack open the time capsule as we each reveal our Top 5 Movies of 2005—the year of gritty visuals, horror revivals, and the rebirth of the Dark Knight. From the stylized chaos of Sin City to the brutal backpacking nightmare of Hostel, to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire and the gritty reboot of Batman Begins, we’re diving deep into what made these films stand out—and what aged like milk. Expect passionate debate, nostalgic rental memories, and a few spicy honorable and dishonorable mentions (we’re looking at you, Doom). Whether you worked the late shift at Hollywood Video or just miss the smell of a freshly opened DVD case, this episode is for you. Hit play, rewind with us, and let’s party like it’s 2005.