In Episode 4 Rich picks his topic and pays tribute to the King of rock and roll, Elvis Presley. The first song unwrapped is the hit 1960s single, It's Now or Never. The fools discuss Elvis as a conduit to introducing what was likely "cutting edge" following the swing and big band music of that era. They discuss the controversy raised around the King's overwhelming success with the rhythm and blues sound when other talented artists were already active in the same genre. The show wraps up with a vivid personal childhood memory of the news of Elvis' death, and a list of famous fans who worshipped him.