All content for Fantasy For Our Time is the property of Nicholas Kotar and is served directly from their servers
with no modification, redirects, or rehosting. The podcast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Podjoint in any way.
Grimdark & the Godless Wheel: A Reflection on Abercrombie’s First Law
Fantasy For Our Time
32 minutes 44 seconds
5 months ago
Grimdark & the Godless Wheel: A Reflection on Abercrombie’s First Law
In this special (and long-promised) episode of Fantasy for Our Time, I dive helmet-first into the final installment of Joe Abercrombie’s First Law Trilogy—a.k.a. the Holy Scripture of Grimdark™ (depending who you ask). I wrestle with berserkers, battle ideologies, and gently poke the gnarled problem of evil with a theological stick.
🛡️ What is Grimdark really saying about human nature?🎭 Can fantasy fiction offer consolation—or only cynicism?⚖️ What happens when the divine is deleted from the narrative framework?
We talk Logan Ninefingers, the Bastard King (whose name totally escaped me mid-video), and the ever-smirking torturer Sand dan Glokta. But we also unpack deeper themes: spiritual fragmentation, Orthodox Christian views on evil, and whether fantasy has lost the mythic courage to hope.
💬 Expect musings, a bit of rambling (forgive me—I hadn’t had coffee!), and sincere reflections on storytelling, suffering, and the wheel of despair that modern fantasy often rides without brakes.
⏰ Timestamps:
00:00 Intro & Life Update01:30 Context: Grimdark, Joe Abercrombie, and First Law Trilogy03:00 The Third Book: Final Reactions and Character Depth04:30 The Northern War & Logan’s Inner Demon06:00 Possession, Evil, and Fragmented Identity08:30 Trial by Combat & Theological Implications10:00 Evil as Lack: Orthodox and Philosophical Framing17:00 Myths After Christ: The Hero's Journey vs. Grimdark20:00 Characters as Pawns: Torturers, Kings & Cowards25:00 No Catharsis, Just the Wheel: The End of Grimdark29:00 What’s Next: Warhammer, Narnia & Summer Plans