It’s become a crisis in the modern classroom and workplace: Students now submit AI-generated papers they can't defend in class. Professionals outsource analysis they don't understand.
We're creating a generation that appears competent on paper but crumbles under real scrutiny. The machines think, we copy-paste, and gradually we forget how reasoning actually works.
Our host, Carter Considine, breaks it down in this edition of Ethical Bytes.
This is the new intellectual dependency.
It reveals technology's broken promise: liberation became a gilded cage. In the 1830s, French philosopher Alexis de Tocqueville witnessed democracy's birth and spotted a disturbing pattern. Future citizens wouldn't face obvious consequences, but something subtler: governments that turn their citizens into perpetual children through comfort.
Modern AI perfects this gentle tyranny.
Algorithms decide what we watch, whom we date, which routes we drive, and so much more. Each surrendered skill feels trivial, yet collectively, we're becoming cognitively helpless. We can’t seem to function without our digital shepherds.
Ancient philosophers understood that struggle builds character. Aristotle argued wisdom emerges through wrestling with dilemmas, not downloading solutions. You can't become virtuous by blindly following instructions. Rather, you must face temptation and choose correctly. John Stuart Mill believed that accepting pre-packaged life plans reduces humans to sophisticated parrots.
But resistance is emerging.
Georgia Tech built systems that interrogate student reasoning like ancient Greek philosophers, refusing easy answers and demanding justification. Princeton's experimental AI plays devil's advocate, forcing users to defend positions and spot logical flaws.
Market forces might save us where regulation can't. Dependency-creating products generate diminishing returns. After all, helpless users become poor customers. Meanwhile, capability-enhancing tools command premium prices because they create compounding value. Each interaction makes users sharper, more valuable. Microsoft's "Copilot" branding signals the shift that positions AI as an enhancer, not a replacement.
We stand at a crossroads. Down one path lies minds atrophied, while machines handle everything complex. Down another lies a partnership in which AI that challenges assumptions and amplifies uniquely human strengths.
Neither destination is preordained. We're writing the script now through millions of small choices about which tools we embrace and which capabilities we preserve.
Key Topics:
More info, transcripts, and references can be found at ethical.fm
