Episode 3 – Pontius Pilate – Villains of the Early Church with Mike Aquilina
Mike Aquilina and Kris McGregor explore the complex figure of Pontius Pilate. Although remembered as a villain and named in the Creed alongside the Virgin Mary, Pilate emerges in the Gospels as a conflicted Roman governor caught between political pressure, personal misgivings, and the volatility of Judea. Aquilina explains how both Jewish and Roman sources portray Pilate as insensitive, often provocative, and capable of harsh actions that destabilized the region. Yet the Gospel narratives show layers—his wife’s troubling dream, his hesitation, and his uneasy awareness that Jesus is innocent—revealing a man far from a simple caricature. Early Christian imagination even produced traditions depicting Pilate’s household as eventually turning toward Christ, reflecting the Church’s instinct to look for the possibility of redemption in every story.
We turn from Pilate’s historical role to the spiritual lessons his failures reveal. Pilate’s most haunting question, “What is truth?”, becomes a mirror the listener must face. Jesus—Truth in person—stood before him, yet fear and self-interest led Pilate to walk away. This invites Cus to consider how often we do the same in our own spheres of influence, whether in public life, family leadership, or ordinary daily encounters. Instead of repeating Pilate’s pattern of avoidance, we are called to face reality with courage, lean on prayer and the sacraments, and let our lives present Christ clearly to others.

Discerning Hearts Reflection Questions

* How does Pilate’s struggle between fear and conscience mirror the moments when I avoid doing what I know is right?
* When have I, like Pilate, chosen comfort or self-protection over fidelity to Christ’s truth?
* What areas of my life require deeper courage, especially when my choices affect those entrusted to me?
* How do I respond when Christ stands before me in Scripture, the sacraments, or other people—do I recognize Him or turn away?
* In what ways do I “wash my hands” of responsibility instead of acting with clarity and integrity?
* How does the witness of the women at the Passion challenge my own consistency and steadfastness in faith?
* What practices of prayer or sacramental life can strengthen me against moral hesitation or cowardice?
* How might I allow Christ’s presence in me to become more visible to others in ordinary daily situations?



An excerpt from Villains of the Early Church
“Jesus was crucified under Pontius Pilate. Countless millions of Christians recite that simple historical fact when they profess their faith. It reminds us that this is real history we’re dealing with. The death and Resurrection of Jesus are not just metaphors or allegories: they really happened at a particular moment in history.
Pilate is our anchor to that historical moment. He is our grounding in historical fact.
But he’s also one of the most fascinating characters in the Gospels. His doubt and dithering in the face of an unpredictable mob make him more than just a villain. They make him human, and we feel real sympathy for him. He’s doing a bad job, but in his position it was nearly impossible to do a good job.”
You can find the book on which this series is based here.

For more episodes in the Villians of the Early Church podcast visit here – Villains of the Early Church – Discerning Hearts Podcast
Mike Aquilina is a popular author working in the area of Church history, especially Back to Episodes