What happens when an Amish pacifist joins the U.S. Army? In this powerful episode of Deformed Theology, we sit down with Kate — a former Old Order Amish woman who left behind horse-and-buggy life, Rumspringa adventures, and strict traditions to follow a radically different path of faith and freedom.
Kate opens up about:
Growing up Amish without cars, electricity, or modern conveniences
Amish beliefs about the end times, the second coming of Christ, and the rapture
The real story behind Rumspringa (it’s not what the movies show)
Shunning, community rules, and the surprising “holy kiss” tradition
Why she chose to leave the Amish at 20 — and how her family reacted
Her shocking decision to join the U.S. Army despite Amish pacifist theology
How her faith in Jesus grew through the struggles of leaving, serving, and raising a family
This conversation blends humor (yes, Amish buggies with sound systems are a thing!) with deep discussions about theology, tradition, and the transforming power of the Gospel. Whether you’re curious about Amish culture, deconstruction of faith traditions, or stories of redemption, this episode will challenge and inspire you.
📌 Chapters / Topics:
00:00 Intro & Amish humor
05:00 Amish beliefs on end times & rapture
20:00 Rumspringa explained
40:00 Leaving Amish life
55:00 Joining the U.S. Army as a pacifist
1:10:00 Faith, Jesus, and finding true freedom
👉 If you enjoy conversations about faith, culture, and theology, don’t forget to like, subscribe, and share this episode!