What if we've been thinking about AI all wrong? This episode challenges the prevailing mental models that frame Generative AI as merely a tool or assistant, proposing instead that AI functions more like a creative instrument—specifically, a drum machine. Drawing parallels to the Roland TR-808's journey from critical disappointment to cultural revolution, we explore how underground adoption of "imperfect" technology can reshape entire creative landscapes. From New York's block parties to Detroit's techno scene, the 808 didn't succeed by sounding like real drums—it created its own aesthetic identity. Similarly, today's AI creators are finding power in embracing artificial qualities rather than hiding them. We examine how this shift impacts creative judgment, audience participation, scene formation, and the fundamental nature of artistic authenticity in an age of algorithmic creativity.