David Kroupa, also known as Dave, is a recently single father of two. He moved to Omaha Nebraska to become close to his children. Since he is single, he is so ready to mingle. So, he signs up for online dating. Soon, he is matched with  Liz Goylar, a single mother of two. Dave is not looking for anything serious and Liz is seemingly okay with that. However, this relationship fizzles out. He soon meets Cari Goylar at his mechanic dealership. She is also on the same dating site as Dave. They click instantly and he even invites her to his apartment. Then, a knock on his door changes everything.