Elliot reflects on the significance of Memorial Day and the transition to Independence Day in Israel, particularly in the context of ongoing conflict and the recent war. He discusses the emotional weight of commemorating those lost while also celebrating independence, addressing calls from some families of hostages to refrain from celebration. We emphasize the historical and existential importance of the state of Israel, arguing that despite failures, the state remains a vital refuge and a fulfillment of a long-held dream for the Jewish people.