In this full-spoiler follow-up to our initial thoughts on Superman, the Coldbros—Troy, Jake, Chris, Scott, and Reese—finally say everything they weren’t allowed to say last time. Plot holes, power levels, pacing issues, parents… nothing is safe.
The Coldbow Podcast liked the film overall - giving it an average of 4.14 stars out of 5. It even impressed Chris, and Chris hates everything that isn't anime.
Was James Gunn’s first shot at rebuilding the DCU actually solid, or are we just too relieved it wasn’t total trash? Did Corenswet bring something fresh to Clark Kent, or is he just hot and tall? Is Lois Lane a decent character this time?
This isn’t a hype session. It’s a breakdown—equal parts praise and petty. We loved some of it, disliked others, and one of us might’ve audibly moaned during a particular building collapsing scene (we’re not naming names).
You’ve seen the movie. Now hear the unfiltered reactions from five guys who care way too much about comic book movies and definitely don’t agree on anything.
Scott
Troy
Jake
Chris
Reese
Want to find out how you can support the Coldbow Podcast? Follow the mome raths below.
Links: