In 1830s Ontario, one of Canada’s most documented hauntings unfolded in the isolated Baldoon settlement. The McDonald family’s story of flying stones, ghostly fires, and a supposed witch’s curse became legend. Two centuries later, historians still debate what really happened. Was it hysteria, fraud or something no one could explain?

This Halloween, we’re digging up one of Canada’s oldest—and weirdest—ghost stories. Long before Netflix true-crime and TikTok ghost hunters, the settlers of Baldoon, Ontario were living through a full-blown paranormal meltdown.

In the early 1800s, John McDonald built a fine new home on the marshlands near the Chenal Ecarte River. Then the chaos began. Stones crashed through windows, furniture moved on its own, and fires sparked from nowhere. Even the family kettle turned violent. For nearly a decade, the McDonalds claimed their home was under attack by an unseen force—until a mysterious “wise woman” told them to make a silver bullet and shoot a black-headed goose that was supposedly carrying the witch’s spirit.

And somehow… it worked.

Two centuries later, The Baldoon Mystery still sits at the crossroads of folklore, fear, and early Canadian history. Was it witchcraft? Frontier superstition? Or the first documented case of mass hysteria in Ontario? In this Halloween special, we trace the real people, newspaper records, and eerie events behind the haunting that turned a quiet farming settlement into the country’s creepiest legend.

All our links:

https://bio.to/canboring

This podcast is hosted two idiots and created purely for entertainment purposes. By accessing this Podcast, I acknowledge that the CIB Podcast makes no warranty, guarantee, or representation as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information featured in this Podcast. The information, opinions presented in this Podcast are for general entertainment and humor only and any reliance on the information provided in this Podcast is done at your own risk. However, if we get it badly wrong and you wish to suggest a correction, please email canadianpoliticsisboring@gmail.com

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.