This episode unpacks one of the most persistent misconceptions in lighting design: the belief that a higher Color Rendering Index (CRI) automatically means better light. We explore how CRI is a measure of fidelity—how closely colors appear compared to a reference—but not necessarily of human preference or beauty. From the warm glow of candlelight, which has a low CRI yet is universally admired, to modern studies showing that people often favor light that enhances saturation even at the expense of fidelity, we question the supremacy of CRI. The discussion also introduces TM-30, a more nuanced set of metrics, and considers how designers can balance fidelity and preference to create lighting that is not only accurate, but also emotionally compelling.